Mandy Moore talks about her first season on This Is Us with a loving wistfulness. “It’s crazy that it’s been 10 years since we filmed it!” she says. But back in 2016, she was totally white-knuckling it.
Though Moore had already pivoted from wholesome teen pop star to Millennial movie fave — A Walk to Remember! Chasing Liberty! — she had never been a series regular. (Some guest roles and a 2005 arc on Entourage notwithstanding.) And the NBC family drama was an especially heavy lift.
Created by Dan Fogelman (Paradise), the emotionally charged This Is Us chronicled the Pittsburgh-based Pearson family across multiple decades and timelines. Moore played Rebecca, mom to two of three biological triplets Kevin (Justin Hartley) and Kate (Chrissy Metz), plus Randall (Sterling K. Brown), whom Rebecca and her husband, Jack (Milo Ventimiglia), adopted when Kevin and Kate’s third sibling, a brother named Kyle, died in childbirth. The show slid between the Pearsons’ past and present. One episode, Rebecca could be tussling with “The Big Three” during their adolescent years in the 1980s; in the next, the older version of the matriarch could be tussling with the adult trio in the present day.
“I remember being so scared,” the actress tells the Television Academy in an exclusive interview. “Everything was so new and terrifying because I had never been in these shoes before. I was like ‘How do we sustain this? How do we keep on with these characters and these stories?’”
Even still, Moore sensed that “Pilgrim Rick” — the show’s first Thanksgiving episode, which aired November 22, 2016 — was unique. The title is a nod to the time that Jack saved the disastrous holiday by improvising a persona out of a makeshift pilgrim hat and entertained his kids in a cheap motel room. Now, adult Kevin and Randall take turns wearing the accessory to honor their late dad. This particular dinner takes a dramatic turn when Randall confronts Rebecca about her longtime secret friendship with his biological father (Ron Cephas Jones). Also, Kate announces she will undergo weight-loss surgery. “It stood out to me,” Moore says. “A lot transpires in it. And it unknowingly set up the entirety of the series.”
Indeed, the Pearsons spent the next six years breaking bread and trying to hash out their complicated feelings for each other. In turn, This Is Us earned 40 Emmy nominations (including three for Outstanding Drama Series) — with both Brown and Jones winning gold. “I’m just one tiny sliver of the show, so I can still watch it as a viewer and appreciate it for what it is,” says Moore, who was nominated for her performance in 2019. “I’m proud of it and love it.”
To honor the key episode’s 10th anniversary, Moore — who will reteam with Fogelman in the Hulu football drama The Land (premiering February 15) — returns to the past one more time with the Television Academy.
This Is Us stars Milo Ventimiglia and Mandy Moore
Television Academy: How much do you recall about filming this episode?
Mandy Moore: I remember filming pretty much all of it. A lot is happening in multiple timelines, and it was a harder episode to shoot.
Why was that?
We had younger kids shooting at night on location. There were just a lot of logistical things. And it was the first holiday episode — we learned that Thanksgiving is a huge part of the Pearson family tradition. So the little details stuck with me, season after season, when we were filming the other Thanksgiving episodes.
Have you watched it recently?
I first rewatched it a couple years ago for the podcast. [Editor’s note: Moore hosts the “This Was Us” rewatch podcast with Brown and co-star Chris Sullivan]. But I was pregnant, and life happens, you know? Then I watched it again last night. I was like, “Oh, wow!” It was so early in the show’s inception! I also didn’t know what I was doing; I probably could have done things a touch differently. As the show went on, Rebecca became a little more solidified. But, live and learn.
At that point, were you still adjusting to playing Rebecca in both the past and present?
Yes!
That seems challenging to track. How did you manage it?
I don't know. I was just trying to keep my head above water. Every new episode, it was like, “Okay, okay.” I took it story by story, episode by episode. I remember being very conscientious. Otherwise, I think I would have been overwhelmed at the totality of, “You’re going to be doing this for 106 episodes, and eventually you're going to be playing it in a future timeline.” If Dan had come to me at the beginning of the show and told me all of that, my head would have exploded.
What was your process when it came to portraying older Rebecca, both physically and emotionally?
For full hair and makeup, by the end [of the show], we were really grooving — it was like three-and-a-half hours in the chair. When I came in at 4:30 in the morning, I told myself that I was going to be super-Zen and take the time to get in this frame of mind because there was always something dramatic in the present day.
I think Rebecca was a joyful woman, but there was also a lot of sadness and shame and guilt. When you lose a spouse and a child, you carry that grief for the rest of your life. So there was just a lot of heaviness in Rebecca's life. She carried it with her even in the way she walked. I always made sure that side of her felt different from the other timelines.
Rebecca’s confrontation with Randall in “Pilgrim Rick” is intense. How was it filming that with Sterling, since he was older than you, the person who played Randall’s mom?
Randall (Sterling K. Brown) in a scene from "Pilgrim Rick."
And I wasn’t a mom yet! But I never didn't feel like Chrissy, Justin and Sterling's mom. That is thanks to the way they treated and supported me. When I showed up on set in my makeup, I truly felt like I just shifted into something different. That was because of the work that I did, but also the way they viewed me.
From my point of view, I knew in every cell of my body that I was the mother of these children — but if they didn't also reciprocate that, it never would have worked. It was very much a hand-in-hand, two parts having to work together cohesively.
Why do you think that scene is so important in the grand scheme of the series?
It laid the groundwork for what my character carried for the rest of the series in the present day [storylines]. This fully realized secret — this nightmare — that she had been carrying for the majority of her children's lives came to the surface. I just don't think that wound ever healed once Randall knew the truth. I believe she carried that pain and grief with her for the rest of her life. That scene is like the ultimate betrayal of the child, if we’re being honest, and I loved playing it.
How much levity was there behind the scenes?
It was fun. I would always tell Milo, “You're really missing out, because you don't get to be with everybody!” Like, it was a party. It was hilarious. There was so much levity. I think because we really liked to be with each other — no matter what was happening in a scene or an episode. Even if a scene was heartbreaking, I never felt that way, because it was just so fun to be around everybody.
And it was hard for me, because I couldn't really laugh in my makeup! [Laughing] It loosened the prosthetics, so I really had to keep my mouth shut. It was hard to do that because we were all so psyched to be around each other. Especially in those early days, it was like, “Oh, this is fun!” We filmed a holiday, and you just felt the spirit of it.
This Is Us star Justin Hartley in a memorable scene from "Pilgrim Rick."
This Is Us seems like it was one of the last series of its kind. In your opinion, why aren’t there more serialized family dramas now?
I think you can't discount Dan and his heart. Maybe we were also the last vestige of what a TV network drama could be. Maybe we’re beyond that now; maybe things have shifted enough in the world, and the way we consumed entertainment at that time just wouldn't pass muster as a bingeable experience. I really believe we were in the right place at the right time.
Entertainment is cyclical. So even though we're living in slightly cynical times right now, I do think this kind of show will come back around again. It’s like every few years the world needs this kind of cathartic entertainment. We need a show that will tap into people’s feelings, a show that recognizes their own choices and experiences.
This interview was edited for length and clarity.
This Is Us is streaming on Hulu.